A Formula for Primes
Consider a polynomial F(x) = x2 + x + 41. Let's check
its values for a few first integers: F(1) = 43 which is prime. F(2) = 47 which is also prime.
Furthermore, F(3) = 53, F(4) = 61, F(5) = 71, F(6) = 83, F(7) = 97,
F(8) = 113, F(9) = 131, all of which are prime. Is it right to conclude that F(x) is a prime
for all integer x?
Let's check a couple more values: F(10) = 151 is a prime; F(11) = 173 and F(12) = 197 are both prime.
However, it's wrong to conclude that F(x) is prime for all integer x. In fact, F(40) = 40*40 + 40 + 41 = 40*(40 + 1) + 41 = 412.
Still, it's interesting that F(x) is prime for all integers from 1 through 39.
G(x) = x2 - x + 41 is prime for x from 1 through 40, and
H(x) = x2 - 79x + 1601 is prime for x from 1 through 80. H(81) = 41*43.
80 is a long run of primes indeed.
R.K.Guy gives more examples where patterns seem to appear when
looking at several small values of a variable. In some cases patterns are indeed real and valid for other values of the variable;
in most cases, as above, they are figments. Guy formulates the Strong Law of Small Numbers:
|
There aren't enough small numbers to meet the many demands made on them.
|
These examples may serve as an introduction into the method of Mathematical Induction which
consists of two steps. The first is verifying a fact for one value of a variable, say, n. The second is assuming the fact
true for an arbitrary value n = k and, on this foundation, proving it for n = k+1. The second step is
quite necessary. As examples above demonstrate, verifying a fact for even a large number of particular cases, does not
in itself prove the fact in the general case.
There is another interesting example:
3! - 2! + 1! = 5
4! - 3! + 2! - 1! = 19
5! - 4! + 3! - 2! + 1! = 101
6! - 5! + 4! - 3! + 2! - 1! = 619
7! - 6! + 5! - 4! + 3! - 2! + 1! = 4421
8! - 7! + 6! - 5! + 4! - 3! + 2! - 1! = 35,899
Of which all are prime. However, the very next one
9! - 8! + 7! - 6! + 5! - 4! + 3! - 2! + 1! = 326,981
is composite since 326,981 = 79*4139.

References
- R.K.Guy, A Strong Law of Small Numbers, in The Lighter Side of Mathematics, R.K.Guy and R.E.Woodrow, eds, MAA, 1994
- Oystein Ore, Number Theory and Its History, Dover Publications, 1976
- J.A.Paulos, Beyond Numeracy, Vintage Books, 1992
- D.Wells, You are a Mathematician, John Wiley & Sons, 1995

Copyright © 1996-2009 Alexander Bogomolny
|